Crittenden’s Cut Above Rum Cask Finished Rye
Crittenden’s Cut Above Rum Cask Finished Rye
Couldn't load pickup availability
Barrel #328 | 8 Years | 118.41 Proof
Mashbill: 55.5% Rye | 28% Corn | 16.5% Malted Barley
Finished in a Circle Hook Rum Cask
The deep mahogany hue immediately hints that this whiskey has spent quality time in oak before receiving a carefully judged rum cask finish. Rather than dominating the spirit, the rum cask adds richness and roundness, complementing the rye’s natural spice without overshadowing its identity.
Nose
The aroma opens with warm baking spice intertwined with rich Werther’s Original candies. Freshly baked buttery shortbread cookies emerge next, layered with silky butterscotch, vanilla bean, and a gentle caramelized sugar note. The rum influence is subtle, lending a soft confectionery sweetness instead of overt tropical fruit.
Palate
A pleasantly thick, buttery mouthfeel coats the palate without becoming syrupy. Rich caramel and buttery shortbread cookies lead the charge, followed by waves of dark brown sugar and toasted toffee. The rye spice remains present but restrained, providing structure rather than heat. Despite its 118.41 proof, it drinks remarkably easy—closer to the experience of a 107-proof whiskey thanks to its exceptional balance and integration.
Finish
The finish is medium in length, beginning with lingering caramel sweetness before gradually transitioning into dry leather, sweet pipe tobacco, and roasted cashew nuttiness. As the sweetness fades, the savory notes linger just long enough to invite another sip.
Overall
This is a beautifully balanced rum-finished rye that never loses sight of its foundation. Instead of masking the whiskey, the Circle Hook rum cask enhances its natural dessert-like qualities while allowing the rye’s spice and mature oak character to remain firmly in control. It’s approachable for its proof, wonderfully layered, and a bottle that rewards slow sipping with each pour.
Share
